Subscribe to our Newsletter
The San Francisco Frontier | Est. 2025
© 2026 dpi Media Group. All rights reserved.

California's Fusion Centers Are Under the Microscope. And Privacy Advocates Are Here for It

A security camera mounted in a white corner.

Photo by Turquo Cabbit on Unsplash

California lawmakers just voted to audit the state’s secretive fusion centers, and honestly, it’s about time. These joint intelligence operations, where federal, state, and local cops all share information, have been operating in the shadows for over a decade without any real oversight. The audit passed this week along party lines, with nine votes in favor, one against, and four abstentions from the Joint Committee on Legislative Audit.

Here’s why people are losing sleep over these places: fusion centers have allegedly become a backdoor for immigration enforcement, directly undermining California’s sanctuary state laws. In one incident that really got people fired up, Immigration and Customs Enforcement basically asked La Habra police to run searches on its behalf at an Orange County fusion center. San Francisco police also supposedly circumvented the city’s facial recognition ban by asking a fusion center to do the dirty work instead. That’s not just sketchy, that’s a straight-up violation of the rules California voters and lawmakers put in place.

State Sen. Sabrina Cervantes, a Democrat from Riverside, spearheaded the audit request after investigations revealed multiple instances where local law enforcement shared license plate reader data with ICE or Border Patrol, both illegal under state law. The California Attorney General’s office has already sent letters to more than a dozen agencies and sued El Cajon for these violations. So yeah, this isn’t theoretical stuff anymore.

The audit will dig into three of California’s five fusion centers, looking at past violations, who’s working there, which private companies are involved, and how much actual oversight exists. It’s a big deal because the last federal audit was in 2013, which is honestly embarrassing. State Auditor Grant Parks will handle the investigation.

Civil liberties groups like the ACLU and Electronic Frontier Foundation have been pushing hard for this transparency, especially given the federal government’s current direction. A 2022 study found fusion centers haven’t actually helped with counterterrorism efforts but have repeatedly labeled racial justice, environmental, and abortion activists as violent extremists. A 2012 congressional report reached similar conclusions, saying these centers endangered civil liberties without providing real security benefits.

Of course, not everyone’s happy. Republican Carl DeMaio called it a “political witch hunt” and claimed we need fusion centers to detect terrorism threats. But former FBI agent Mike German countered that transparency is exactly what you need during national security challenges. You can’t have effective counterterrorism when agencies are operating outside public scrutiny.

Cervantes made it clear she’s not trying to shut down fusion centers entirely. She just wants accountability. And with surveillance tech becoming increasingly invasive, demanding to know what these secretive operations are actually doing seems pretty reasonable.

AUTHOR: pw

SOURCE: CalMatters